2006 Hanover Football Results: 4-6; 4-3 HCAC
| Date | Opponent | Time |
| Sept. 2 | at Thomas More (Ky.) | 25-23 Loss |
| Sept. 9 | at Butler | 30-20 Loss |
| Sept. 16 | Washington & Jefferson (Pa.) | 35-0 Loss |
| Sept. 30 | Rose-Hulman* (Homecoming) | 41-8 Win |
| Oct. 7 | Mount St. Joseph (Ohio)* | 24-0 Loss |
| Oct. 14 | at Manchester* | 32-14 Win |
| Oct. 21 | Defiance (Ohio)* | 20-10 Loss |
| Oct. 28 | at Bluffton (Ohio)* | 7-6 Win |
| Nov. 4 | Anderson* (Senior Day) | 27-3 Win |
| Nov. 11 | at Franklin* | 35-10 Loss |
* denotes Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference games
2005 Hanover Football Results: 4-6: 3-3 HCAC
| Date | Opponent | Time |
| Sept. 3 | Thomas More (KY) | 12-7 Win |
| Sept. 10 | at Washington & Jefferson (PA) | 56-20 Loss |
| Sept. 17 | Bridgewater (VA) | 56-42 Loss |
| Sept. 24 | at Waynesburg (PA) | 34-17 Loss |
| Oct. 1 | at Mount St. Joseph (OH)* | 41-35 Win OT |
| Oct. 8 | Manchester* (Homecoming) | 48-7 Win |
| Oct. 15 | at Defiance (OH)* | 28-14 Loss |
| Oct. 22 | Bluffton (OH)* | 33-19 Loss |
| Oct. 29 | at Anderson* | 35-28 Win |
| Nov. 12 | Franklin* (Senior Day) | 45-15 Loss |
* denotes Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference games
2004 Hanover Football Results: 6-4; 5-1 HCAC
| Date | Opponent | Time |
| Sept. 4 | at Thomas More (KY) | 31-30 Loss OT |
| Sept. 11 | Washington & Jefferson (PA) | 27-15 Loss |
| Sept. 18 | at Bridgewater (VA) | 72-24 Loss |
| Sept. 25 | Waynesburg (PA) | 34-31 Win |
| Oct. 2 | Mount St. Joseph (OH)* (Homecoming) | 29-10 Loss |
| Oct. 9 | at Manchester* | 31-7 Win |
| Oct. 16 | Defiance (OH)* | 28-7 Win |
| Oct. 23 | at Bluffton (OH)* | 37-20 Win |
| Oct. 30 | Anderson* (Senior Day) | 21-0 Win |
| Nov. 13 | at Franklin* | 24-7 Win |
* denotes Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference games
2003 Hanover Football Results: 8-3; 6-0 HCAC
| Date | Opponent | Time |
| Sept. 6 | at Urbana (OH) | 34-17 Win |
| Sept. 13 | at Thomas More (KY) | 33-30 Win OT |
| Sept. 20 | DePauw | 39-20 Loss |
| Oct. 4 | Manchester* (Homecoming) | 57-18 Win |
| Oct. 11 | at Defiance (OH)* | 55-38 Win |
| Oct. 18 | Bluffton* (OH) | 52-10 Win |
| Oct. 25 | at Anderson* | 48-19 Win |
| Nov. 1 | at Washington & Jefferson (PA) | 42-28 Loss |
| Nov. 8 | Mount St. Joseph* (Senior Day) | 26-24 Win |
| Nov. 15 | at Franklin* (Victory Bell Game) | 33-24 Win |
| Nov. 22 | at NCAA Playoffs | |
| Nov. 22 | at Baldwin-Wallace (OH) | 54-32 Loss |
* denotes Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference games
2002 Football Results: 10-1; 6-0 HCAC
| Date | Opponent | Time |
| Sept. 7 | Urbana (OH) | 47-14 Win |
| Sept. 14 | Thomas More (KY) | 36-3 Win |
| Sept. 21 | at DePauw | 31-21 Win |
| Oct. 5 | at Manchester* | 49-7 Win |
| Oct. 12 | Defiance (OH)* (Homecoming) | 57-35 Win |
| Oct. 19 | at Bluffton* (OH) | 47-21 Win |
| Oct. 26 | Anderson* | 41-23 Win |
| Nov. 2 | Washington & Jefferson (PA) | 35-14 Win |
| Nov. 9 | at Mount St. Joseph* | 49-14 Win |
| at Mariemont High School | ||
| Nov. 16 | Franklin* (Senior Day) | 57-12 Win |
| NCAA III National Playoffs | ||
| Nov. 23 | Wittenberg (OH) | 34-33 Loss |
| * Heartland Conference games |
2001 Football Results: 5-5; 4-2 HCAC
| Date | Opponent | Time |
| Sept. 8 | DePauw | 30-27 Win |
| Sept. 15 | Thomas More (KY) | 28-21 Loss |
| Sept. 22 | at Washington & Jefferson (PA) | 35-10 Loss |
| Sept. 29 | at Alma (MI) | 56-14 Loss |
| Oct. 6 | Defiance (OH)* (Homecoming) | 33-13 Loss |
| Oct. 13 | at Bluffton* (OH) | 34-15 Win |
| Oct. 20 | Mount St. Joseph* (OH) | 36-14 Win |
| Oct. 27 | at Anderson* | 51-27 Loss |
| Nov. 3 | at Manchester* | 29-16 Win |
| Nov. 10 | Franklin* (Senior Day) | 54-6 Win |
| * Heartland Conference games |
